I’ve Read All of Elsie Silver's Books—Here’s My Ranking of Them.

      March 11, 2025

      

      The Everygirl’s product choices are selected by the editorial team. If you purchase anything through our links, we may earn an affiliate commission at no additional cost to you. We recommend only the products we truly love.

      

      

      If you’re like me, you appreciate a bit of romance in your escapist reads. The most skilled writers effectively blend just the right amount of tension and playful dialogue into their narratives. Elsie Silver excels at this. She crafts her characters in such a way that you never want to leave their imaginary small towns. Elsie first gained recognition four years ago with her Gold Rush Ranch series, but it was her second series, Chestnut Springs, that truly brought her to my attention, as well as many others. Since then, she has become a beloved name in the romance genre, alongside authors like Ali Hazelwood and Emily Henry. The small towns, swoon-worthy cowboys, loving families, and heartfelt moments she creates consistently draw me back to reading.

      If you’re on the lookout for books that balance sweetness and spice, with characters that will leave you smiling and kicking your feet, here’s my ranking of Elsie Silver’s works to guide your introduction to this new favorite author.

      Note: Elsie Silver’s books are standalone yet interconnected and can be enjoyed in any order, though some references may be missed if you haven’t read others.

      12. Powerless

      

      Elsie Silver

      

      To Jasper Gervais’s admirers, he’s the charming, skilled hockey star on screen. But to Sloane, he remains the lost boy with a heart of gold. Thus, when her life crumbles on the day she is meant to marry someone else, it’s no surprise he steps in to rescue her.

      Powerless is the third book in the Chestnut Springs series.

      

      Unfortunately, I couldn’t get into Jasper and Sloane’s story. Jasper is a professional hockey player who finds a sense of belonging with the Eaton family. Sloane is his ballerina best friend who harbors feelings for him. After her wedding falls through, they embark on a seemingly aimless road trip that leads to them finally acknowledging their feelings. The road trip element is manageable, but it felt somewhat unengaging. While their sexual chemistry is undeniable (Elsie has a knack for creating captivating connections), the rest of the narrative felt rather flat. I found it to be a lackluster and unexciting read.

      11. Hopeless

      

      Elsie Silver

      

      Beau Eaton is a dashing military hero with a troubled past. Bailey Jansen is a shy outcast working as a bartender, hailing from a less privileged background. He’s thirty-five, fully a man, and also her fiancé—well, more accurately, her pretend fiancé.

      Hopeless is the fifth book in the Chestnut Springs series.

      Please be aware that this book deals with serious themes, including PTSD and family abuse. After leaving the military, Beau comes back to Chestnut Springs but struggles to fit in with his family following his experiences. Meanwhile, Bailey is trying to regain control of her life after supporting her family, who tends to exploit her. Sadly, the growth of their relationship didn’t develop enough for me to fully invest in them as a couple. While there were some positives, the age difference felt awkward, and I was not fond of how Bailey's curiosity about sex and virginity was depicted, especially given Beau’s age and unresolved mental health challenges. I love Silver’s writing, but this book did not meet my expectations.

      10. A False Start

      

      Elsie Silver

      

      One night, they were complete strangers: the town’s irritable recluse and a stunning girl in the bar. Until they weren’t, because Nadia Dalca isn’t just any girl; she’s his best friend’s younger sister and strictly off-limits.

      A False Start is the fourth book in the Gold Rush Ranch series.

      A kiss in a bar bathroom with your best friend’s little sister—what could possibly go wrong? Griffin and Nadia meet under the influence at a bar, and they don’t reconnect for another two years. Fate brings them together again as they work on the ranch while Nadia helps veterinarians before returning to school. It’s a typical “she’s too young, but so mature for her age” narrative. Despite their feelings for one another, Griffin keeps pushing her away until he can’t anymore. Throughout most of the book, I found myself frustrated with Griffin, almost until he finally acknowledges her need for independence and begins to apologize. There was a frustrating dynamic throughout, as he seemed torn between affection and reluctance. By the end, we finally see clarity, but it felt a bit underwhelming. Overall, the story was just average, especially when compared to other books that handle this