Nothing frustrates me more than smudging mascara, so I've discovered 7 that stay put.

      Hello, I'm Grace, and I've dealt with oily eyelids for as long as I can remember, which has driven me to find the best smudge-proof mascara available. Choosing the perfect mascara can be challenging, and finding one that stays put has often felt nearly impossible. However, as a beauty editor, my dedication to my work is strong, so over the past few months, I've tested various popular formulas—ranging from the best budget mascaras to top tubing mascaras and the best options for sensitive eyes—to determine which meet my expectations for longevity and which result in black smudges under my eyes by day's end. I've worn many of these mascaras during work, on nights out, and even during workouts to create a definitive list of smudge-proof formulas that I trust to withstand my oily eyelids. Below, I've compiled my top selections, so if you're in search of a mascara that remains intact throughout the day, I highly suggest you keep reading. I've assessed the best smudge-proof mascara formulas.

      **The Best Smudge-Proof Mascaras, Tried and Tested**

      - **Best smudge-proof mascara overall:** MAC MACStack Waterproof Mascara (£27)

      - **Best natural smudge-proof mascara:** Victoria Beckham Beauty Vast Lash Mascara (£32)

      - **Best smudge-proof mascara for bottom lashes:** Clinique Bottom Lash Mascara (£22)

      - **Best voluminous smudge-proof mascara:** Benefit BADgal BANG! Volumizing Mascara (£27)

      1. **MAC MACStack Waterproof Mascara**

       **Best smudge-proof mascara overall**

       This is a cult favorite in the mascara industry, the MAC MACStack Mascara. Being someone with oily eyelids, I always prefer the waterproof variant, and believe me when I say this formula remains intact. It's a highly buildable mascara that provides a fantastic false-lash effect, and the long-lasting product keeps your lashes looking elongated and elevated all day long. This mascara is a guaranteed 10/10 in my book.

       **Pros:** Buildable formula, provides length and lift, long-lasting

      2. **Victoria Beckham Beauty Vast Lash Mascara**

       **Best natural smudge-proof mascara**

       This is a more natural-looking option from Victoria Beckham Beauty. This smudge-proof mascara adds natural volume to the lashes and gives a lovely, fluttery finish that makes it seem like I've always had long lashes. It never clumps, even when I apply two to three layers, and it won't leave any transfer under my eyes by the end of a long day.

       **Pros:** Adds natural volume, non-clumpy, chic packaging

       **Cons:** A bit pricier

      3. **Clinique Bottom Lash Mascara**

       **Best smudge-proof mascara for bottom lashes**

       Due to my oily eyelids, I usually avoid mascara on my bottom lashes. However, when I feel like enhancing my makeup, this is the best smudge-proof formula for the lower lash line. It features a tiny wand that makes application easy and reaches tricky spots, ensuring the long-lasting formula never transfers to my under-eye area.

       **Pros:** Tiny wand for easy application, non-transferable

       **Cons:** Only suitable for lower lashes

      4. **Benefit BADgal BANG! Volumizing Mascara**

       **Best voluminous smudge-proof mascara**

       After trying every single Benefit mascara, this one is my favorite for achieving a voluminous and smudge-proof result. I prefer using it in the evenings for that false-lash appearance, as the slim brush allows me to coat each lash easily. It also offers good length, making it a great all-rounder in my opinion. Plus, it’s water-resistant—not that I would swim in it, but it does enhance its longevity.

       **Pros:** Adds volume, thin brush for easy coating

       **Cons:** Can become slightly clumpy at times

      5. **L'Oréal Paris Paradise Castor Oil Enriched Mascara**

       **Best smudge-proof mascara for sensitive eyes**

       Along with oily eyelids, I also have quite sensitive eyes (I know, makeup artists cringe at my presence), which is why I love the L'Oréal Paris Paradise Mascara. You might wonder if the castor oil would cause smudging issues, but surprisingly, this formula is really long-lasting. I wear it nearly every day as it has been formulated for those susceptible to eye irritation, and the gentle formula consistently performs well.

       **Pros:** Safe for sensitive eyes, more affordable

       **Cons:** Not as volumizing as others on this list

      6. **Charlotte Tilbury Pillow Talk Push Up Lashes Mascara**

       **Best lifting smudge-proof mascara**

       I initially bought this mascara to achieve a fuller, more voluminous look, but I was pleasantly surprised by how well it lasted throughout the