We Tested the Must-Have Winter Coat That Every New Yorker Has—Here’s Why It Deserves the Buzz.

We Tested the Must-Have Winter Coat That Every New Yorker Has—Here’s Why It Deserves the Buzz.

      If you’re even slightly online, you've likely come across the East Coast saying that gets tossed around from November to March: "Are you really from New York? Do you own a big, black puffer jacket?" We do have puffer jackets, and while they may not all be big and black, they are undeniably superior. I'm referring to every New York girl and the internet's beloved winter coat: The Aritzia Super Puff. Originating in Vancouver to tackle harsh wind-chill and frigid temperatures, the Aritzia Super Puff has found a home among New Yorkers. Favored by influencers, college students, and daily commuters alike, it has become a symbol of both warmth and style. It’s not merely a jacket; it serves as a social marker. Spotting one on the subway gives you a hint about the wearer’s coffee choice. Its shiny surface and cocoon-like shape signify winter chic, blending functionality with the effortless cool that seems unique to Aritzia. Yet, with numerous puffers available and an increasing number of dupes appearing on TikTok, the question lingers: Is the Aritzia Super Puff truly deserving of its hype? Six of our editors, each varying in height and size, put it to the test in the frigid wind tunnels of downtown Manhattan and the hectic bustle of weekend tasks to determine if this cult favorite maintains its status.

      Aritzia Super Puff Review:

      **Aritzia Super Après Puff in Matte Pearl**

      Size: Small

      Height: 5'0

      Nikki's review: I've never been fond of puffer jackets because I’ve never found one I considered stylish. Every winter, my friends rave about their Aritzia puffers, claiming they’re a lifesaver, especially in the coldest months of January and February in NYC. I usually just nod along, thinking I’d rather stick with my elegant long wool coats. However, upon hearing that this winter might be particularly frigid, I felt anxious and started searching for the warmest, fashionable winter jackets. Before long, I ended up on the Aritzia Super Puff page exploring the options and fell for The Super Après Puff. This jacket is the shortest of the puffers, so it won't keep my lower half warm, but it excels at keeping my upper body cozy and looks polished, suitable for someone who pays close attention to their style. The mock neck collar, which creates a stylish funnel-neck look when fully buttoned, and the matte material give it a sleek appearance. I also appreciate the fleece-lined pockets that warm my hands when I forget my gloves and the cuffs with thumbholes that add extra warmth. Although it's not fully winter yet, I've already worn this jacket on some 40-degree mornings, and it has been a lifesaver. I can confidently say this jacket is about to become my best friend.

      **Aritzia Super Puff Mid in Black**

      Size: Extra-Large

      Height: 5'9

      Ana's review: I might be slightly biased, but as a native Floridian, my favorite winter item is a gold Aritzia Super Puff. I bought the Aritzia Super Puff Long jacket a few years ago, and since moving to New York, I've worn it nearly every day in winter. It's seen significant wear (including a few holes and stains since it’s a lighter color). Therefore, I was eager to try the Aritzia Super Puff Mid. Being on the taller side, I wanted a jacket that reached just past my hips without feeling like I was wrapped in a marshmallow-filled blanket—something the extra-padded Super Puff Long does already. I traveled to SoHo to try on the Mid style and was pleased that it hit right at my thighs. Just like with all Aritzia Super Puffs, I can effortlessly wear it with my favorite white t-shirt and jeans—the down filling keeps me warm without needing many layers. If you have an apple-shaped body or a larger chest like I do, you might find it beneficial to size up; I chose the Aritzia Super Puff Mid in my true size (around 16/18), but it felt a bit snug around my midsection. Most classic Super Puff silhouettes, including the Mid, are available up to 2XL, making them plus-size friendly.

      **Aritzia Super Puff Xtrashorty in Mochi Pink**

      Size: Extra-Large

      Height: 5'4

      Aniyah's review: After moving from Florida to NYC for four years, I can’t believe I went so long without a Super Puff. Everyone praises its warmth and durability. My fellow editor Natalie Gray Herder has had hers for six years, and it’s still in great condition. Initially, I aimed for a classic black puffer to match my neutral winter wardrobe, but I decided to shake things up by choosing this baby pink cropped puffer. It adds a whimsical and fun touch to even the most casual

We Tested the Must-Have Winter Coat That Every New Yorker Has—Here’s Why It Deserves the Buzz. We Tested the Must-Have Winter Coat That Every New Yorker Has—Here’s Why It Deserves the Buzz. We Tested the Must-Have Winter Coat That Every New Yorker Has—Here’s Why It Deserves the Buzz. We Tested the Must-Have Winter Coat That Every New Yorker Has—Here’s Why It Deserves the Buzz. We Tested the Must-Have Winter Coat That Every New Yorker Has—Here’s Why It Deserves the Buzz. We Tested the Must-Have Winter Coat That Every New Yorker Has—Here’s Why It Deserves the Buzz. We Tested the Must-Have Winter Coat That Every New Yorker Has—Here’s Why It Deserves the Buzz. We Tested the Must-Have Winter Coat That Every New Yorker Has—Here’s Why It Deserves the Buzz. We Tested the Must-Have Winter Coat That Every New Yorker Has—Here’s Why It Deserves the Buzz. We Tested the Must-Have Winter Coat That Every New Yorker Has—Here’s Why It Deserves the Buzz. We Tested the Must-Have Winter Coat That Every New Yorker Has—Here’s Why It Deserves the Buzz. We Tested the Must-Have Winter Coat That Every New Yorker Has—Here’s Why It Deserves the Buzz. We Tested the Must-Have Winter Coat That Every New Yorker Has—Here’s Why It Deserves the Buzz.

Other articles

Dancer Isabella Boylston on Challenging Ballet Stereotypes, Creating Content, and Paying Attention to Her Ankles Dancer Isabella Boylston on Challenging Ballet Stereotypes, Creating Content, and Paying Attention to Her Ankles She combines ballet with elegance. I'm not giving up my jeans or trousers this winter, but I'm definitely tempted by these skirt trends. I'm not giving up my jeans or trousers this winter, but I'm definitely tempted by these skirt trends. Check out the winter skirt trends that have made their way from the runways to the wardrobes of fashion enthusiasts, including stylish sweater skirts and striking red minis. I Recently Explored Zara for the Most Stylish Affordable Winter Coat Trends—Here Are 7 You Should Be Aware Of. I Recently Explored Zara for the Most Stylish Affordable Winter Coat Trends—Here Are 7 You Should Be Aware Of. They are simply excellent. Indeed, affordable cashmere lounge sets are available—here are the 17 finest options. Indeed, affordable cashmere lounge sets are available—here are the 17 finest options. Loungewear can still exude elegance while keeping you comfortable. These budget-friendly cashmere sets embody both qualities perfectly. Access them here. My lifeless, dehydrated skin was signaling for help—this dermatologist-approved moisturizer became the solution. My lifeless, dehydrated skin was signaling for help—this dermatologist-approved moisturizer became the solution. It truly merits all the excitement surrounding it. If you have any of these 11 powder blushes in your makeup bag, beauty editors will recognize your great taste. If you have any of these 11 powder blushes in your makeup bag, beauty editors will recognize your great taste. A powder blush is essential for every makeup bag. In this article, we present the 11 top choices, as recommended by beauty editors and a celebrity makeup artist.

We Tested the Must-Have Winter Coat That Every New Yorker Has—Here’s Why It Deserves the Buzz.

Check out our editors' complete review of the popular Aritzia Super Puff.