Only these 11 mascaras can lift my persistently straight eyelashes.
Everyone has distinct preferences regarding mascara. Some people seek lengthening formulas, while others opt for volumizing ones to enhance lash thickness. Some are devoted to flexible comb wands, while others prefer bristle wands for their lashes. Personally, I favor curling mascaras to assist my persistently straight eyelashes. However, I often struggle to find a mascara that maintains the curl throughout the day. This is where lifting mascaras prove valuable. In the past, I relied on waterproof mascaras to secure the curl, but let's face it—they can be tricky to remove without a proper makeup remover. Some curling mascaras work for me, but others fail to hold up against my straight lashes. On the other hand, lifting mascaras effectively support the lashes at the root for a wide-eyed appearance. With countless options available, finding an effective mascara can be daunting. Thankfully, as a beauty editor, I have the opportunity to test various mascaras, and I've compiled a list of the best lifting mascaras I've encountered. Rest assured, these lash-lifting formulas will keep your eyelashes looking fabulous.
**Best Lifting Mascaras**
- **Best Overall:** Lancôme Lash Idôle Mascara (£28)
- **Best Affordable Mascara:** L'Oréal Paris Big Deal Mascara (£14)
- **Best Lash Lift Mascara:** The Ordinary Lash Curl Finisher (£9)
- **Best Luxury Mascara:** Hourglass Unlocked Instant Extensions Mascara (£31)
- **Best Lengthening Mascara:** L'Oréal Paris Telescopic Extensionist Mascara (£14)
1. **Lancôme Lash Idôle Mascara**
- **Pros:** Curls, defines, and lengthens lashes with lasting hold; no clumping, flaking, or smudging.
- **Cons:** Not the most volumizing option.
I genuinely appreciate all of Lancôme's mascaras, but in terms of lifting and maintaining a curl, this one is the best. The curved, flexible wand effortlessly glides through lashes, lifting, lengthening, and defining each with a lightweight formula that feels soft to the touch. One coat provides a natural, lifted look, while a second coat adds drama without any clumping. While it's not the most volumizing, you'll be pleased if you prefer a more naturally defined lash appearance.
2. **Ilia Limitless Lash Mascara**
- **Pros:** Lifts, lengthens, and defines; nourishing ingredients; doesn't smudge or flake; available in black and brown; easy to remove.
- **Cons:** Not the most volumizing formula; on the pricier side.
The hype surrounding the Ilia Limitless Lash Mascara is well-deserved. It features a flexible comb with varying bristle lengths—the shorter side lifts from the root, while the longer side helps lengthen and separate lashes. It keeps lashes uplifted all day. While technically not a tubing mascara, it dissolves with just warm water, making it great for sensitive eyes. Loaded with conditioning ingredients like shea butter and beeswax, it helps keep lashes soft and healthy.
3. **L'Oréal Paris Paradise Big Deal Mascara**
- **Pros:** Lengthens, defines, volumizes; lifts and curls; buildable formula for a natural or false lash effect.
- **Cons:** Frequently sold out in stores.
I was amazed by the results when I used this mascara. Admittedly, I applied several coats of the L'Oréal Paris Paradise Big Deal Mascara, but look at the lift! The flexible wand hugs the lashes for a quick boost and holds throughout the day. It’s an excellent multitasker that lengthens, curls, lifts, and volumizes without clumping or looking spidery. It even competes with higher-end brands, and I can't be without a tube now.
4. **The Ordinary Lash Curl Finisher**
- **Pros:** Maintains curled lashes; offers a natural-defined look; no smudging or flaking; feels light.
- **Cons:** Doesn't add volume or pigment; may feel sticky.
Although The Ordinary Lash Curl Finisher isn’t technically a mascara, if you're after the look of a lash lift without heavy product, give this clear mascara a try. Simply curl your lashes and apply this clear formula from root to tip to lock in the curl all day. It gives the appearance of naturally curled lashes. If over-applied, it can feel a bit tacky, but one coat provides enough hold and subtle definition.
5. **Lancôme Lash Idôle Curl Goddess Mascara**
- **Pros:** Curls and lifts with all-day hold; lengthens and volumizes for a wide-eyed effect; lightweight and flexible.
- **Cons:** Large wand may feel cumbersome for smaller or hooded eyes; can clump if over-layered.
If you haven't noticed yet, I adore Lancôme mascaras, and the Lash
Other articles
Only these 11 mascaras can lift my persistently straight eyelashes.
They compete with a lash lift.
